wine review: 96+ points – Tedeschi Maternigo Amarone della Valpolicella Riserva 2016

February 2025

Matt’s review: Tedeschi Maternigo Amarone della Valpolicella Riserva 2016, sourced from the Barila vineyard on the Maternigo estate in eastern Valpolicella. 2016, a five star vintage, also marks the inaugural vintage of Riserva Amarone for Tedeschi from the Barila single vineyard. This beautiful cru vineyard, although early in its tenure under Tedeschi’s care, is already showing promise for producing some of the finest wines available in Valpolciella. A blend of 40% Corvina, 40% Corvinone, and 20% Rondinella, the grapes were harvested early fall then underwent 100 days of appassimento (grape withering/drying), 40-day fermentation, 90-day maceration, followed by 48 months in Slavonian oak, then four years and counting of bottle refinement – all contributing to its impressive depth, harmony and overall complexity. From the moment you approach the glass, this Amarone entices with its impressive aromatic complexity. The nose offers an inviting blend of dried dark fruit, black cherry, a touch of spice, with hints of cacao and wet stone minerality that add depth and intrigue. The palate repeats these rich flavors, layering cassis and plum over a backdrop of well-integrated tannins and vibrant acidity all in a very elegant package. The finish is long with great intensity, demonstrating the wine’s impressive depth and balance. A wine of great structure, showcasing the quality of the Barila vineyard, the careful winemaker’s touch, and the resulting potential for long term aging. While already in a beautiful spot, it will undoubtedly evolve gracefully over the next 3-4 decades, rewarding those with the patience to defer gratification as the wine continues to develop and refine its complexity.

This inaugural vintage of Maternigo Amarone Riserva represents the promising future of the Barila vineyard. While I’m eager to taste the 2019 vintage (another 5 star vintage) down the road, the 2016 is an outstanding expression of ultra premium Amarone which you’ll want to add to your cellar. A must-have for collectors and connoisseurs who appreciate enjoying the best of Valpolicella’s terroir. Enjoy now, or let it rest for years to come—either way, it promises an exceptional experience. Tasted February 2025. 96+ points – Matt Steeves http://www.quercusvino.ca